Letter: a McGill story
On June 17, one of my classes started a 3-part “Indigenous Policies” unit. Our instructor facilitated the first session, which was a review and discussion of the Truth and Reconciliation Report. Very quickly, I felt moved to speak up. I suggested to… Read More
On June 17, one of my classes started a 3-part “Indigenous Policies” unit.
Our instructor facilitated the first session, which was a review and discussion of the Truth and Reconciliation Report.
Very quickly, I felt moved to speak up.
I suggested to our instructor the need for Indigenous facilitation in discussing Indigenous issues. It is an act of reconciliation to defer to the Indigenous voice and perspective; and would honour the expertise and wisdom of Indigenous facilitators who professionally deliver reconciliation workshops.
I also mentioned pre-surveys as an example of best practice. This would allow the presentation to be adjusted in tone and content. For example, if the majority of students would benefit from more history or information. Or, the class might be farther along in their awareness, and could focus on a deeper dive into reflection and daily practices in Allyship.
The instructor’s response was that the Dean had also asked about the pre-survey, checking in with instructors on how they are delivering TRC focused discussions. Our instructor told the class he didn’t need a pre-survey because he “could handle anything that came up”
What came up?
In the first unit, we had an unfortunate and inappropriate mix of elders sharing 60s scoop traumas, with uninformed voices declaring that “disproportionate rates of Indians in jail are all due to Fetal Alcohol Syndrome.” What makes it inappropriate is the fact elders are encouraged to “share” their stories of surviving residential schools, with no guarantee of a safe container. In our third unit, we had a classmate ask: “What does TRC” stand for? This was after having been assigned to read the report as pre-work, and after three units and two Indigenous speakers.
Why pre-survey?
- To know where the class is: does the class need more history/information? Are they beyond that, and working on self-awareness regarding bias and assumptions? Are they Indigenous or Indigenous-allies and focusing on championing change in their workplaces, needing discussion around how to do that?
- To break into groups if there are big differences – some groups may need very elementary information, while others were Indigenous and should have the opportunity to share a session without hearing stereotypes or offensive terminology.
- When Indigenous participants are involved in these conversations, there is a mental health component. Do we know what impacts happen after the class ends, after a residential school conversation? Do they have mental health and emotional supports in place at home?
- Part of reconciliation is deferring to Indigenous voices. To me, this means these conversations should have only had Indigenous facilitation.